Frisco, 1928. A French sex farce at the Green Street Theater in North Beach, and a blonde in the title role who turned it into the hottest ticket in town. She claimed to be a ballerina, Naana Wartova, from Moscow. Offstage she was Elaine Worth. The cops said she’d been born Carrie Ellsworth, over in Richmond. Pick one. She didn’t care.
Men swarmed her like bees to honey, and they kept turning up dead. Handsome Gerri Ferri, a racketeer who told her he was in the pineapple business, took six slugs through a locked bathroom door. Of course, pineapple was gangster-speak for bomb. A month later, the man police fingered for the hit was lying on a clay road outside Sacramento with five bullets in him and her pictures in his pockets. Then Rene Fabri at the bottom of a cliff on Rockaway Beach, beaten and shot. Her leading man went out a sixth-floor window into a Tenderloin light well, and a coroner’s jury called it an accident. The fixer, Frank Grupico, for whom she signed in as his wife at City Prison before she collapse from pills and gin fizzes caught a bullet of his own in 1932.
All she wanted was love, she claimed.
By 1932, a blonde named Alice Dunn was playing Zee Zee in Hollywood. She wouldn’t say whether she’d ever been Elaine Worth, only that Death seemed to follow her wherever she went. This is Part Two of the Elaine Worth story. Pour yourself a cup of coffee and listen to Frisco: The Secret History, Episode 39, “Elaine Worth: Where There Is Honey, There Are Dead Bees.”
TRANSCRIPT:
Hi, welcome to Frisco: The Secret History. I’m your host, Knox Bronson. I have a great episode for you today, Part Two of the Elaine Worth story, the gorgeous actress whose presence turned the failing production of the “Easy For Zee Zee,” show at the Green Street Theater in North Beach into a smash hit in 1928. Today we delve into five of her boyfriends, who, over a ten month period, three would be shot and one would mysteriously exit a sixth floor window in the light well of a Tenderloin apartment. There was one more who was shot and killed a couple years later, after she was out of the picture.
Before we get going, I want say thank you to Walter Haas at Graffeo Coffee Roasters at 735 Columbus Avenue in San Francisco. They have a shop in San Rafael as well.
Graffeo was founded in 1935 and has been selling coffee beans to the public and the best restaurants near and far ever since. I have been drinking Graffeo Coffee since I lived around the corner on Mason Street back in the Seventies. Right now, they have a special subscription offer on Graffeo.com, that is g r a f f e o dot com: subscribe to a regular delivery of coffee and receive a free gift bag of beans. They sell whole beans, or will grind to your request. I am really happy to say that Graffeo Coffee is a founding sponsor for the Frisco: The Secret History podcast. I am thrilled to be associated with such an historic and iconic San Francisco brand. Graffeo beans are, as it says on the package, “Simply the finest coffee in the world.” It’s true. Give Graffeo a try. You will thank me.
[intermezzo]
This is a little longer than usual episode because Elaine Worth was a girl who, simply put, drew swarms of men to her like bees to honey. Several ended up in the Italian Cemetery in Colma.
[intermezzo]
December 19, 1928. Fifteen miles east of Sacramento, a clay road runs off the Fair Oaks–Folsom highway toward a powder house, where the Garfield Johnson Mining Company stored its dynamite and nitro, out where nobody goes unless they have a reason.
Somebody had a reason.
Two dead men lay on the road that hugged the meandering American River. The nearby town of Fair Oaks, 100 miles north-east of Frisco, had seen gangster action for the control of the illegal booze trade recently. The days were cold, the nights freezing and thick tule fog blanketed the area in the morning.
Vito Pileggi had been both stabbed and shot and, apparently, thrown from a car. Tire marks ran off the road to his body and back onto it. He identified himself as a rancher in the South Bay Area but was known by police to be a member of Frisco’s Italian Black Hand Society. According to police, the motive for his death was unclear.
He was about thirty-five, well-dressed, and sported a black pompadour. In his pockets were a stiletto with a broken point, half a dozen empty rifle shells, several cartridges, a loaded revolver, a blackjack, a flashlight, and $50 in cash.
San Francisco Police Inspector Allen McGinn, head of the homicide squad, said, “Frank Boca and Scariso went for a ride to Sacramento and took along this man Pilleggi of Morgan Hill. Scariso must have thought they were taking him for a ride, because he suddenly stuck a knife into Pilleggi.
“Then Boca, as we figure it, shot Scariso to death, finished off Pilleggi with a couple of bullets and dumped both bodies out of his car.”
“We traced Scariso out to a place in the outer Mission [in San Francisco] run by Frank Boca, known ‘strong man of the Sicilians.’ The late Genaro Broccolo, by the way, was an intimate associate of Boca. I think the two were partners.
Let me interject here: I talked about Broccolo, a nasty extortionist who preyed on North Beach businesses in an earlier Bones Remmer episode. Scariso was wanted for the killing of Gerri Ferri, whom we will get to shortly. The cops were looking for Scariso.
Inspector McGinn went on:
“Boca hid Scariso and we never did get him. Then Scariso must have got ambitious or Boca got tired of him. The two went for a ride to Sacramento and took along this man Pilleggi of Morgan Hill.”
“Scariso must have thought they were taking him for a ride, because he suddenly stuck a knife into Pilleggi. Then Boca, as we figure it, shot Scariso to death, finished off Pilleggi with a couple of bullets and dumped both bodies out of his car.”
That doesn’t quite jibe with other police statements that Scariso was shot while trying to flee.
McGinn went on, “That left Boca as the kingpin of the gang. He lasted less than a year.”
[intermezzo]
Have you noticed how convoluted these gangster stories get?
It’s December 19, 1928. We have Pilleggi dead, stabbed and shot and left by the side of the road.
A hundred and twenty yards away, on the shoulder of the old clay road, lay the body of Alfredo Scariso, whom the San Francisco police sought for the killing of Gerri Ferri a month earlier.
There was a jar of gasoline near his body, wrapped in a San Francisco newspaper of November 25, containing an account of Ferri’s murder.
In his pockets were several pictures of Elaine Worth.
He had five bullets in him.
Two in the arm.
One in the knee.
One in the head.
One in the chest.
To understand why two men ended up dead on a clay road outside Sacramento, we have to go back a month or so, to an apartment at 490 Lombard Street, where a man the papers called “Handsome Gerri Ferri” lay dead. Six bullets, a bloody handprint, and his body on the floor.
And now, a partner who was now lying dead on a narrow clay road near Sacramento in between a powder house and the American River.
Over the next few years, five men, over whom this seductress seemed to hold an Aphrodite-like sway, would come to violent ends.
Before 1928 was out, police were working on the theory that quarrels over her had set off the chain of shootings.
[intermezzo]
Who was this thespian enchantress?
On November 25 th 1928, The Chronicle said that Naana Wartova was her real name, then a few paragraphs later, Carrie Ellsworth.”
A year later, on October 1, the Bulletin identified her as Miss Wortova, from Russia. trained in ballet as a child, with “a decided success in her native city of Moscow.” Still another newspaper identified her as Elaine Worth with the stage name of Naana Wortova..
Which was it?
Based on all the stories I’ve found and digested, the preponderance of evidence suggests that Carrie Ellsworth of Richmond became Elaine Worth offstage and Naana Wortova on stage in Frisco, and the Russian ballerina story was part of the act. After all the drama ended here, she resurfaced in Hollywood a few years later with a new alias and would neither admit or deny having once been Elaine Worth. We will get to that later. Suffice it to say, the girl could tell stories as well as she could entice men or transform a failing sex comedy in a tiny North Beach theater into a word-of-mouth must-see smash hit in a matter of days.
Before we go any further, I’d like to mention that I identified Elaine as Russian-born in the last episode. At the time, it fit with what I had uncovered so far. My apologies.
Easy For Zee Zee had been running less than three months when Handsome Gerri Ferri was murdered in his apartment. A week before the murder, Elaine had moved out of there and back home to her parents’ house in Richmond across the bay, where her two year old son also lived. It is unclear as to when she had moved in. Police found some bills and letters addressed to her on Ferri’s bureau, along with a love note for Gerri, “Sweetheart — Please remember Elaine and love me always … Your pal Elaine.”
She had married George Chapman Moses, an actor, at seventeen, in Santa Ana, California, in 1916. Later, she married a theatrical man, as described in the press, named Middleton, who was the father of the child. No further information is available about him, the wedding, or the child. He seems to have disappeared rather quickly.
In 1930, she got an annulment for the marriage to George Moses, so it seems that, if the dates lined up, she had been dabbling in a bit of bigamy. Her grounds for the annulment were that she had been underage at the time of the wedding. Under oath, she told the court, “I looked so young… that I knew no one would issue me a marriage license without the consent of my parents. So I put on some of my stage makeup to simulate age, donned a long, oldish dress and a terrible hat, and the deputy county clerk who gave us the license never was the wiser.”
Compared to Elaine’s other romantic entanglements, at least Middleton and Moses got out alive, so far as we know.
[intermezzo]
Gennaro Ferri, also known as Handsome Gerri, told Elaine upon meeting her that he had interests in the jewelry business and the pineapple business. Well-dressed, he passed himself off as a regular guy, a citizen as Tony Soprano might call him. In truth, he was a North Beach racketeer and former Chicago gangster known to be as Frisco’s mob boss in 1928. Pineapple, at the time, was gangster-speak for bomb. He told Elaine he had moved to Frisco for his health. Obviously, that didn’t work out.
At some point she moved in with him. She claimed she didn’t like the character of his associates and they had fought about it and she moved out, or so she told one newspaper reporter.
On the evening of November 23, Gerri and his neighbor Ralph Casina went out to the theater. Easy For Zee Zee perhaps? The theater was just a few blocks away from their apartment building. We will never know, but I wouldn’t be surprised. It’s damn near impossible to let a woman like Elaine Worth go.
Gerri and Ralph got home just before midnight. Arriving at the building, Ralph entered the apartment he shared with his wife, Rosie, number three. Gerri came in to say hi briefly and then went upstairs to his own apartment. A few minutes later, he came back downstairs to have coffee with the couple.
Gerri stayed for about fifteen minutes before he returned to his own place.
A few minutes after that, at 12:30 a.m., the Casinas heard a fusillade of bullets, a woman screaming, feet running hard down the stairs and out the front door of the building. A gunman had fired six bullets through Gerri’s locked bathroom door, where he crouched in terror. Five hit their mark.
“Ferri must be killed!” Rosie said to her husband when she heard the shots. The Chronicle paper reported that Mrs. Casina did not say why she predicted Ferri’s death when asked. The Casina’s also stated that they heard a woman scream during the commotion
The story went on: “Still others reported they had heard a woman’s scream just before the shooting. The police got so many stories they didn’t know what to believe. Some of the stories, it appeared, were told for the sole purpose of confusing investigators.”
The screaming woman was never identified.
The gunman, later identified through a bloody handprint on the woodwork, Alfredo Scariso, got away that night, but later took a ride with Frank Boca out to the countryside and ended up doing forever downward dog in between the clay road and the gently flowing river it hugged.
I want to mention, quickly, that I wrongly assigned the date of Ferri’s murder as April 28th, 1928, in the first Bones Remmer episode. That was about a year ago. My apologies.
The day after the murder, jaws were flapping, birds were singing, and everybody had a different angle to share.
Elaine talked to the Examiner. She said, “I loved him. But I didn’t like his friends. They carried guns … I told Gerri he would have to choose between me and his friends. He wouldn’t give them up. So I left.”
Also that Ferri had asked her to marry him and was quite the jealous type: “Gerry hit Baby-Face on the head with a gun and to keep away from me.”
That would be “Baby-Face” Biaggini, who owned the cafe on ground floor of the Green Street theater, where patrons could dine with the cast before the show. The Los Angeles Evening Post-Record told the story this way:
[typewriter]
“Baby-face,” he snarled, “lay off Elaine! If you don’t, I’ll blow your head off and your goddam cafe off the map!” It was only a short time until police found Gerri, dead in his Lombardo street apartment, with a dozen little round holes gushing blood. The murder went unsolved. Police found bills for Elaine Worth in Ferri’s papers. Police grilled the girl and Baby-Face.
“All right,” ” Elaine, screamed under the third degree, “I’ll tell you all I. know. I loved him. Sure, Baby-face was nice to me. It made Gerri mad. They had a fight. Then Gerri was killed.”
But Biaggini was never charged with the crime.
Elaine, after a while, left off weeping and went back to the theater. Then a hunt was started for Alfred Scariso, another gangster close to Ferri.
“It we find him,” police said, “we’ll solve this killing.’
On Dec. 19, police found Scariso dead. Dead on the Fair C&ks road, 12 miles from Sacramento.
He had been shot four times in an automobile. He too, had admired.”Zee Zee.’
In the spring of 1929 she was keeping company with another sharp-featured dandy, Rene Fabbre, a member of Ferris gang.”
[end typewriter]
In the same article, she said it was just “a friendly attachment,” and she didn’t lived with Ferri, but there were the letters addressed to her at Ferri’s place which suggested otherwise. And the love notes. The police found a second note that read: “I would not take this chance to write to you with every one watching me if I did not really love you so” — signed only “Happiness.”
The police told the Chronicle that she had lived with Gerri up to a week before his murder and that they had had an argument then and that it wasn’t the first.
“Baby-Face” Biagini walked into Detective Captain Duncan Matheson’s office on his own to clear himself: he said that he and Ferri fought because Ferri thought he was “infatuated with Miss Worth.” And that “Our dispute was not a serious one and Miss Worth went back to Ferro.”
The same article said Ferri had been arrested “only last week” on suspicion of having gone gunning for Biagini, “just prior to his quarrel with Elaine Worth and their separation.”
Elaine’s mother claimed that Elaine had never lived with Ferri or any other man and that she sometimes stayed with friends in the city after her shows. She would not reveal Elaine’s married name to the police or the press.
Police said that Elaine had no connection to her sweetheart’s murder. Indeed, she seemed heartbroken.
Handsome Gerri Ferri’s funeral was held at the huge, twin-spired Saints Peter and Paul church in the heart of Little Italy on Tuesday, November 27th. It was a quiet funeral, quite like that of any North Beach resident. There were equal numbers of uniformed police and plainclothes homicide detectives among the hundred or so mourners scanning every face at the funeral in the hope that some meager clue to Ferri’s murder might appear.
The weather that early winter afternoon was typical for San Francisco. The fog had burned off in the morning and it was cool and moderately cloudy with a gentle breeze off the Bay.
In the sanctuary, Elaine sat in the front row of mourners on an ornately carved pew as the priest made the case for Handsome Gerri Ferri’s soul to reside in Heaven.
Elaine said “He may have been a gangster to the outside world but he was always a gentleman to me.”
She went on with her show without missing a performance.
[intermezzo]
In 1895, the Howard-Wilson Publishing Company of Chicago bought up six thousand acres north east of Sacramento and divided them up into small farm lots. They aggressively marketed the plots to Midwestern doctors, lawyers, and other professionals as the Sunshine Colony, an upscale citrus paradise devoid of saloons, heavy traffic, and other evils of big city life. A few people bit, but by the late 1920s, the area mostly remained an unpoliced patchwork of isolated homesteads, heavily wooded areas, dirt roads, and uncultivated orchards.
It was the perfect place to unload hijacked shipments of bootlegged booze, settle scores, and dump bodies undetected under the thick cover of winter tule fog.
Frisco Police Lieutenant Charles Dullea and Detective Sergeants Frederickson and Porter traveled to Fair Oaks to investigate the the murder scene on the nineteenth of December. As best they could, they reconstructed the sequence of events and the motives. As is often the case in the gangster world, there were no definitive answers, like who was driving, whose car it was, who stabbed Pileggi, was it Boca’s plan to kill both men from the beginning? If so, what had been his story to get them to travel that far from Frisco? It was a half-day trip, for both the crooks and the cops, including a ferry ride with the car to Oakland or Berkeley and then up what was then known as the Lincoln Highway and would later become Interstate 80 to Sacramento and then further east.
Frank Boca was never charged with anything related to the case.
On July 30, 1929, Inspector McGinn would report, “Boca got his. Maybe Broccolo did it, I don’t know, but Boca was found riddled to death in his car in the sand dune region of Noriega Street and 29th Avenue. He also had been stabbed.” This doesn’t have anything to do with our story today, but I thought it worth mentioning.
On December twenty-first, Acting Police Chief William Quinn and homicide chief Dullea held a press conference declaring war on “alien gunmen” in San Francisco — and said that quarrels over Elaine Worth had inspired the murders.
He said they had found a jar of gasoline in the dust next to Scariso’s body, which was three-hundred feet away from Pileggi’s body, wrapped in a newspaper dated November twenty-fifth, carrying the story of Gerri Ferri’s murder. The had no explanation as to the origin of the jar of gasoline, its intended purpose, or its significance.
Quinn talked about the contents of Scariso’s pockets: an unmailed letter in Italian to a friend asking him to fetch his clothes from his place at 1005 Powell Street on Nob Hill and bring them to him where he was hiding out at Frank Boca’s place. The police were after him.
Quinn also revealed that Scariso had several snapshots of Elaine Worth in different pockets. One of them had been pierced by the bullet to his heart.
[intermezzo]
Rockaway Beach, on the coast just south of San Francisco, by the city of Pacifica, is a small, crescent-shaped cove tucked into a valley between steep hills Cold and windy year round, it’s framed, north and south, by dramatic high cliffs that jut out into the Pacific Ocean. In the 1920s, access to the beach was difficult, it would be ten years before Highway One reached the city, making it the perfect location to offload schooners full of Canadian booze. The ship would anchor offshore in the bitterly cold nighttime fog beyond the breakers and signal its arrival and location with flickering lights for the lookouts onshore. They would row out and bring the priceless cargo to shore. At one point, there was a rope and pulley system that helped them traverse the surging waters to the ships and back to the shore, allowing them to empty a fully loaded schooner in one night.
It was here, on the sandy beach, on the night of April twenty-ninth or the thirtieth of 1929—news reports differ—that the mangled and lifeless body of Rene Fabri was found. He had been beaten, shot, and his throat sliced. It is possible he had been thrown off the cliff next to which he lay as well.
Fabri had been an associate of the Gerri Ferri’s before Gerri had been murdered back in November. Police identified him as a French immigrant gambler and procurer, a polite term for a pimp. They found in his pocket an address book with one hundred women in it.
The Modesto Bee reported, “Disreputable haunts of the San Francisco underworld were singled out by police to-night as they sought to locate the murderer of a man known among numerous acquaintances as Rene Fabri, among Chinatown habitués such as Jack Leaf and among gamblers as Rene Renaud.”
There was always a huge French presence in the world of San Francisco prostitution.
The police went through his address book as well, interviewing the many women in there. After a few days, Sheriff James McGrath of San Mateo County received an anonymous letter identifying Fabri’s murderer as Jean Pietrero of Millbrae. We’ve met Sherriff McGrath before, a thoroughly corrupt lawman operating under the the auspices of Bones Remmer.
The letter charged Pietrero with slaying Fabri in a quarrel over a game of cards in a peninsula roadhouse. Pieterero turned himself in and was taken before Distriet Attorney Franklin Swart. After questioning, he charged with murder. Strangely, I can find nothing about the murder or Pietrero, like a trial or an extradition after June of 1929. The story just disappeared.
The ongoing investigation did to the breaking up of an international white slave racket in which Febri was deeply involved, leading to multiple arrests and deportations.
Nor can I find any record of Elaine bemoaning the loss of Rene, nor a protestation of her undying love. This was, according to police a murder over money, not her for once.
Resilient Elaine would move on, as always. Quickly.
[intermezzo]
Ferri’s murder had hit Frank Grupico hard, but not hard enough to keep him from pursuing Elaine after both Ferri and Rene Fabri were out of the picture. She had that power over men.
Grupico was a fixer and pretended to not be a gangster. Even so, he had been Gerri Ferri’s best friend. He walked in the shadows between the underworld, the cops, the judges, the lawyers, the bail bondsmen, the jailers, the prisons and parole boards, the politicians, everybody who had a hand on multitudinous levers of power within the little city by the bay.
That’s not to say he wasn’t adverse to pulling off a score now and then.
Back in November of 1928, Grupico and Ferri had been arrested at Stockton and Union Streets for being in possession of an automatic pistol, a sawed-off shotgun and a full set of burglar tools. The officer considered the items to be evidence that they were heading out to pull a hijacking job. Both men denied it. He hauled them off to jail. I cannot find the outcome of that case, or if they were even charged. I suspect not.
In early August of 1929, Grupico was jailed along with another man for attacking a woman in a fancy restaurant on the ground floor of a resort at Hyde and Vallejo Streets. Resort was newspaper-speak for bordello.
This story is so weird and convoluted, I am just going to share the front page story with a huge banner headline, “ZEE ZEE IN COMA,” in the San Francisco Call-Bulletin, August fifth, 1929.
The subheads read:
S. F. ACTRESS FAINTS AT CITY JAIL
Rushed to Emergency Hospital, Denies Taking Poison Tablets
And the story read:
[typewriter]
Naana Wortova, sensational star of “Easy for Zee Zee,” racy French farce playing its eleventh month at the Green Street Theater, today was the center of a deeper mystery than ever. She lay in a deep stupor in Harbor Emergency Hospital, where she was brought after falling unconscious in city prison last night.
At a late hour today, Miss Wortova still was unconscious at the hospital, except for a few instances, when she was able to cry for water. Doctors sald that it would be impossible to move her until she regained consciousness.
The woman, who at various times has been known as Elaine Worth and who registered both at city prison and the hospital as Mrs. Elaine Grupico, 1160A Vallejo street, bad been visiting Frank Grupico at the prison.
Grupico is being held there in leu of $50,000 ball and faces two serious statutory charges fled against him by Mrs. Grace Krewson, 246 Mason street, following an alleged attack in a restaurant conducted by Mimi Imperato at 1918 Hyde street, July 21.
The attractive young blonde who figured as the supposed cause for the murder of Jerry Perri, beer runner, and her alleged sweetheart last year, was suffering from some poison or opiate, according to Dr. William E. Styan of the emergency medical staff.
Police found tablets in her purse, but In a few moments that she was conscious she denied vehemently that she had taken them.
Though the woman registered as the wife of Grupico, her manager Sid Goldtree, and Grupico denled they were married. Goldtree said that the woman would be a bigamist If she had married Grupico.
The mystery was deepened when police took the name of a woman who accompanied Elaine and who said she was Mrs. L. Sweeney of 1275 Third avenue, and claimed to be her sister in law through her “marriage” to Grupico.
This woman was about to take valuable jewelry, a fur coat and other expensive effects worn by Elaine when brought to the hospital. But Goldtree protested, saying that the woman was no relation and had no right to her effects.
Elaine’s mother, living in Rlehmond, came to the hospital with Elaine’s seven-year-old son and told Dr. William E, Styan that the actress might have fallen victim to reducing tablets. The mother said Zee Zee had been using the tablets to lessen her weight.
[end typewriter]
Let’s do a quick summary: Grupico was in city jail for attacking a woman in a bordello restaurant on Russian Hill. Elaine went to visit him, signed in as Mrs. Grupico, promptly passed out, and was rushed to Harbor Emergency where she lay in a coma. A woman showed up and tried to steal her fur coat and jewelry by claiming to be her sister-in-law before Sid Goldtree intervened and said the woman had no claim to Elaine’s possessions.
The next day, Elaine emerged from her coma.
When she came to on August sixth, she explained that she had used the name Mrs. Grupico because: she “thought it would be easier to gain entry there through use of that name.”
She went on to say, “I love this Frank so much I couldn’t sleep nights. I couldn’t eat. My work in the play was going down, down, down. I was so distracted that I was forced to take a sedative to quiet my nerves and get a bit of sleep.”
“I took two sleeping tablets Sunday and then two or three gin fizzes. I
guess the gin and the veronal didn’t mix well. The next thing I remembered
after entering Frank’s cell was when I awoke in the hospital here.”
She begged nurses to bring Grupico to her bedside for just five minutes.
Asked by an Examiner reporter about being married to Elaine, Grupico said that he was not married and had no intention of tying himself up for life with any woman. In fact he would as soon be in jail where he was and Elaine must have dreamed they were married.”
This is the end of the Frank Grupico Elaine Worth story for now. Frank in jail, Elaine cracking the boards and dazzling the audiences in Easy For Zee Zee every night.
[intermezzo]
Two weeks later, Elaine entered the Coroner’s Office at 650 Merchant Street on the edge of Chinatown. Upon seeing the body of Robert Chapman, with whom she shared the spotlight nightly as her stage sweetheart, she burst into hysterics and seemed to be on the verge of collapse.
Who wouldn’t be? In less than ten months, three of her boyfriends, Handsome Gerri Ferri, Alfredo Scariso, and René Fabri, had been brutally murdered, two reportedly in fights over her affections, the other in a card game gone wrong.
Perhaps Elaine had grown tired of her gangster boyfriends ending up dead, stabbed, shot, beaten, thrown off cliffs, or merely jailed.
So why not Robert? For nearly a year they had shared the stage as the romantic leads in Easy For Zee Zee. As actors, they had had amazing chemistry onstage, so why not off? He clearly liked her. Of course, all men did.
He came from a good family, was a U.C. Berkeley graduate, and lived with his father, a prominent attorney in San Francisco, in a beautiful house at 1601 Oakland Avenue in Piedmont, an affluent charter city tucked into the hills of Oakland. The house is still there. It is quite lovely.
He was as far from a La Cosa Nostra gangster as a hopeful girl could get.
Now her latest sweetheart, some said her fiancé, lay on a metal draw in the morgue.
On the twenty-second of August, the Chronicle posited, “Murder, suicide, or accident?” The article went on to say there were finger marks on the windowsill in the light well, indicating Chapman had struggled fiercely to avoid his fateful plunge.
The building’s janitor, Paul Bernardo, said he found Robert’s friend, a bruised and bloody Allen Hoffman in the hallway. Hoffman said to him, “I’m looking for my friend — he disappeared.”
Some officers didn’t believe Chapman had been thrown out the window by the two mystery visitors.
Their theory: Chapman, frightened by the assault of the two men on his friend,” leaped, forgetting the height in his terror — perhaps thinking he was in Hoffman’s old fourth-floor apartment, which had a balcony outside a similar window; Hoffman had moved up to the sixth floor only a week before. There are other police officers who are just as convinced that Chapman was thrown out the window and that his death, therefore, was murder, citing the scuffle marks on the sill as evidence.
James Boyle, occupant of the apartment adjoining Hoffman’s, told police of hearing two men approach the door, of sounds of scuffling, and a sudden scream.
That was all the evidence police had–that and finger marks on the sill of the open window indicating Chapman had struggled fiercely to avoid his fatal plunge.
In an October twenty-ninth retelling of the deaths surrounding Elaine, the Examiner reported:
[typewriter]
The police found the sill of the open window to the light well scratched by the frantic fingers of Chapman where he had evidently clawed and grappled for his life when the visitors started to throw him out. They had then apparently beaten him until he let go and fell to his death.
[end typewriter]
There was a dramatic illustration of Chapman hanging onto the sill and men pounding on his hands with the caption: Marks Upon the Window-sill of the Apartment Showed That Young Chapman Had Hung There, Desperately Trying to Climb Back, While His Unknown Assailants Beat His Clutching Hands Away—And, Like Elaine’s First Fiance, They Picked Him Up Dead.
Somewhere along the way, rumors began to swirl, and they could have come from Elaine herself, that Elaine and Robert had been secretly engaged and that the party on the night in question had been an engagement party, with the wedding set for the very next day. By October, local newspapers considered this to be fact.
Within days of Chapman’s untimely death, Sidney Goldtree, under immense pressure from the press and city officials, closed down the show that had made Elaine famous.
When the show reopened three weeks later, Alice Worthing, the original Zee Zee, replaced Elaine in the lead role.
In January of 1947, our favorite columnist, Freddie Francisco, born Robert Patterson, wrote a short history of the Green Street Theater in the Examiner, which I will read for my next episode. Freddie chimed in on Robert Chapman’s death with this:
[typewriter]
As the years went by, a certain aura of rather dingy tragedy became associated with the place. There was certainly enough reason for this. Robert Chapman, leading man in “Easy for Zee Zee,” was murdered one night after the show, thrown down the light well of his apartment building.
[end typewriter]
No matter what some might have said about Bob Patterson, the man had his sources and was always tapped into the whisper-stream of the world beneath.
[intermezzo]
So what became of that wily Frisco political go-between Frank Grupico, the one who was in jail when Elaine fell into a coma from an overdose of sleeping pills and gin fizzes? He was no Romeo like Handsome Gerri Ferri or pimp René Fabri. He’d been in jail in jail for attacking a woman and when asked about being married to Elaine, he said she must have dreamed it. A real charmer.
On April 25, 1930, he was arrested with Little Italy extortionist Genaro Broccolo in the heart of North Beach after a shootout in which no one was injured.
But Elaine wasn’t done with him. On the night of October 13, 1930, a man named Ralph Esposito shot and killed Genaro the Magnificent Broccolo in North Beach. Esposito told police Broccolo had demanded fifty dollars from him and threatened to blow up his house with a pineapple, a bomb. Tucked into the Examiner’s story the next morning was this:
[typewriter]
Recently Elaine Worth announced that Frank Grupico, well known North Beach character, was her husband.
[end typewriter]
So Elaine, for whatever reason, wasn’t letting that chestnut go, and I guess the paper still found her newsworthy.
Do you remember in a long ago Bones Remmer/La Cosa Nostra episode that when Ralph Esposito was being held in the city jail for the murder of Genaro the Magnificent, dozens of Little Italy residents paid visits to the jail to thank him? Esposito was found not guilty by reason of self-defense.
That was the kind of company Frank Grupico kept.
Police said he and his friend Luigi Malvese carried on Broccolo’s operations after “Genaro the Magnificent” was gone. On Sunday, May 15, 1932, Frank Grupico was shot, the Examiner said, “by an asserted victim,” by which they meant a victim of extortion.
Three nights later, Malvese was driving down Columbus near Filbert when a man jumped onto his car’s running board and shot him dead through the open window. The man hopped off the rolling car before it crashed into a parked car on the side of Columbus Avenue. Two of Genarro the Magnificent’s former underlings had been killed three days apart.
Elaine Worth, the gorgeous star of the smash hit play “Easy For Zee Zee,” which took Frisco by storm, didn’t appear anywhere in that particular story. But Frank Grupico was the fifth of her boyfriends to die a horrible and violent death.
Some girls have all the luck.
[intermezzo]
On January eighteenth, 1932, a reporter from the Los Angeles Evening Post-Record interviewed actress Alice Dunn at her hotel.
The story read:
[typewriter]
The deep blue of Alice Dunn’s eyes shadows with pain. Four men have died because they looked into her eyes and found something there that pleased them, All four have died violent, strange deaths. Behind Alice Dunn lie four violent deaths, broken hearts and sorrow and a strange love life that rivals the wildest fiction.
The vivacious blonde actress, protagonist of tragedy, is playing in the lead in “Easy For Zee Zee,” a risque comedy now showing at the Hollywood Music Box theater.
In her rooms at the Regent Hotel the young actress admitted today that Death, sudden and swift and violent, has crossed her path many times. Dressed in a jet black morning gown, she sat in her bedroom and admitted that she had known four men murdered in or near San Francisco.
[end typewriter]
I should mention that Frank Grupico was still alive up in Frisco. For three more months, anyway.]
[typewriter]
Alice Dunn—her name used to be Elaine Worth, her friends say—flung wide her hands in a despairing gesture. The green ribbons on her decollette gown shook as she trembled at the thought of death.
Alice will not admit that her name WAS Worth–nor will she deny it. Men who knew Elaine Worth have died suddenly, and maybe Alice Dunn wants to forget those tragedies which came into her life when she was just 18 years old.
[end typewriter]
In this interview, the last I can find with her anywhere, Elaine said, “Why should Death follow me always? I hate Death. I may have to change my name again and go away to China or anywhere. I’ll go away again, I suppose, to get away from the feet of Death that always seem to follow me wherever I am.
But the newspaper called her the vivacious star of “Easy For Zee Zee” who was currently playing Hollywood, a place where she might again find other men to lure with her charms.
#SanFranciscoHistory #TrueCrimePodcast #Frisco #SanFranciscoNoir #FriscoTheSecretHistory